The Sand Witch Project

Plot
The episode opens up with all the remaining players in Economy class. Ruchi is complaining that if he said everyone won, shouldn't everyone be in first class, but Lizzie reminds her that Chris said he needed first class for something else, and what Chris wants he takes...from them. Caelan is angry, realizing that now he is left with only Andy and Jen, since Alex, JP and Catherine all were eliminated and everyone else from his team was with Serena and Joseph.

Caelan (CONF): I really gotta find some allies

Thankfully for him, Jen did rejoin his alliance back in Niagara Falls, when they talked in economy class and it was clarified that it really was Marisa behind Grant and Anna's elimination and not her. But their disadvantage numbers-wise means they could easily eliminate him and his remaining two alliance members. He decides he has to expand his alliance, but is aware of both the alliance in Team Victory and the one in Team Firecrotch so knows there are limited players left to ally with. Andy and Jen are laughing about something and Jen begins snorting causing the other contestants to laugh, but this annoys Caelan. He decides to go out for a walk, and passes by first class, where Chris and Chef are talking to a shadowy figure. Chef insists they don't use the figure, because he/she is vicious and will take the contestants out, and Chris says if they do it will be good for ratings. Caelan gasps, causing all three to look over. Caelan turns his head the other way and the figure is right there and Caelan screams.

The contestants land back at the Hollywood film set where the western challenge took place. He states todays challenge will be based off another movie genre, this time though, there will be two different genres combined. The first is horror movies, and the second is mystery movies. All the contestants figure that there was probably going to be "murder" in this challenge. Andy asks where Caelan is, and Chris says that is related to the challenge. Chris says their challenge will be to solve the mystery, and discover the truth behind Caelan's disappearance. The first person to successfully figure out who did it and get their entry into the submit box somewhere on the lot, will win, and pick three people to share their immunity with. Chris replies there will be a twist later on, and yells go. The contestants are confused, and don't really know what to do. Chris says there are clues throughout the lot. The contestants split up and go looking for clues, everyone individually to try and get that immunity. All the different sets on the lot are based off of different movie genres.

Kacvinsky, Sam and Myra end up looking around the western set. While there, they see something that could help any of them win the challenge, the submit box. They agree to keep it a secret, and go check it out. There is an electronic screen, that is blank except for a beeping underscore that signals you can type things. Both decide to go looking for clues somewhere else since there wouldn't be any near the submit box itself.

Ruchi, Katie, and Nupur are looking around the alien film set, which is inside a giant fake spaceship, and hear a thump. They run through the giant spaceship, thinking it could be a clue, when the shadowy figure appears and grabs Katie, who was running in the back. Ruchi and Nupur yell after Katie, but the shadowy figure and Katie are both already gone. Ruchi and Nupur look at each other, both of them nervous, and quickly continue go back to searching the set, but more cautiously.

Lizzie, Cooper, Liz and Nathanael decide to search around the kung-fu movie set, which is a giant dojo. Inside, they see a lot of different paper fans, each with letters on them. They begin to sort them out to try and decipher what was seemingly a code.

Cooper (CONF): Hell yeah, finally something mentally challenging

Channing, Nathan, Serena and Andy are searching around the monster movie set, which is a giant city, but can't find anything. They see Kacvinsky, Sam and Myra exiting the western film set looking satisfied, so they choose to go inside and see what they had found. Kacvinsky, Sam and Myra decide to go to the superhero film set, which is inside a giant supervillan's evil lair.

Jen sees the shadowy figure walk by with Katie in a sack, and decides to follow it. She sees it drop off Katie right next to Caelan, standing on a mat with Chris behind a fake wall posed as just part of the film lot. A wall of TV screens is the other side of the wall, and Caelan, Katie and Chris are watching everything on those TV screens. This gives Jen an idea, and she runs off.

At the pirate-themed movie set, Clayton and Ashton are digging for a clue at an X they found. Eventually, Clayton digs up the treasure chest, and opens it. Clayton and Ashton look in, wide-eyed, immediately having figured out what was inside and begin sprinting to try and find the submit box. The camera pans back to the treasure chest to show a war helmet and an army boot.

Sydney is walking with Colin and Ian on the horror film lot, when Ian gasps, but is silenced and kidnapped by the shadowy figure. Sydney and Colin look around to see Ian gone, and look concerned. They hear something behind a fake bush, and go look behind it, just to find Jen. She says she was looking for clues, and goes with Sydney and Colin. She starts asking Colin who he doesn't like on the show, believing he likes everyone. Colin says he likes everyone, but doesn't really trust Caelan. Jen smirks, and pretends to be in disbelief. She questions him further, but he says he doesn't really know why, but just doesn't trust him. She asks Sydney the same question, but Sydney shrugs saying she likes everyone.

Jen (CONF): Colin and Sydney are way too likable to go too much farther in this game

Back at the western film set, Channing, Nathan, Serena and Andy are looking for clues when Ashton sprints by. Ashton turns her head and sees the submit box, so she dives behind a fake bush. Clayton is then seen sprinting by, but doesn't see the submit box so he just keeps going. Ashton runs out to the submit box, types in the name, and it turns green and four immunity passes pop out. Ashton cheers and Chris ends the game and calls everyone to his hiding place behind the wall, including the "killer". When everyone gets there, Sydney sees that Caelan was watching the whole thing, and looks worriedly at Colin, realizing what Jen did. Caelan is seen glaring at Colin. He tries to avert his glares, but Caelan persists. Chris pulls off the mask of the killer to reveal…

…

…

…

...

...

…

…

Old Man Jenkins! Which was also a mask, and pulled off to reveal...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

.......Justin! Who would be returning to the game. Everyone gasps, and Ashton is smiling with her correct guess. She saw the boot and helmet and realized it was who was eliminated in the Boot Camp challenge. Chris congratulates Ashton, and tells her to choose three people to share immunity with. Clayton is smirking, knowing she will pick him, when she picks Liz, Ruchi, and Sam. Clayton gets angry with Ashton, saying he is the one that revealed the clue, but Ashton tells him to deal with it.

At dinner, there is a lot of debate between Jen and Colin, with Caelan pushing hard to send Colin home. He is saying to look at the threats, which gets a lot of people's attention, but really it's for personal reasons. Caroline agrees with taking out Colin, while Kacvinsky thinks it should be Jen, causing tension between the alliance. Caroline and Kacvinsky are trying talking to all the members individually to try and get them to vote their way. Kacvinsky argues it's way too soon to be turning on each other, but Caroline says they need to make an exception to take out the mega-threats.

In the meantime, Ashton is trying to eliminate Caelan, and telling everyone that his antagonistic ways have been enough.

At the Hollywood Award ceremony (the same one used in Lone Ranger), Chris says he will be handing out Gilded Chris awards again as a sign of safety. The first goes to Ashton followed by Ruchi, Sam, and Liz. He then tosses them out to Nathan, Serena, Kacvinsky, Sydney, Joseph, Nupur, Channing, Andy, Cooper, Lizzie, Ian, Katie, Clayton, Caroline, Myra, Emily and Nathanael.

The bottom three are Caelan, Colin, and Jen, and the next Hollywood award goes to Caelan, who sighs with relief causing Ashton to roll her eyes. The bottom two are Colin and Jen, and the final Hollywood award goes to...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...Jen.

Kacvinsky gets mad at Caroline for eliminating someone so nice, but Caroline argues he is a threat. Caelan reveals in the confessional he accomplished two things at once, eliminating a threat and causing infighting in an alliance. He says he was angry at Colin for what he said, but it doesn't matter the order in which they all go home, because they're all going at some point.